Twenty Questions For The Intelligent DesignerAutor tekstu: Bernard Katz
Why are there so many species? Doesn't an
Intelligent Designer imply that it could have created a few species designed so
well that there would be no need for them to be multiplied without end?
Why did the Designer have to periodically destroy his creations? Why were
they designed so poorly that they could not adjust to these changes?
Why did the Designer, from time to time, destroy much of the earth by
having it collide with comets, producing in turn, overbearing heat and cold,
which then destroyed a great many of the life forms it had created?
Why did the Designer create celestial systems like planets, suns, comets,
exploding stars, black holes and galaxies that demolish one another?
Why is the Designer allowing the cosmos to expand continuously?
Why is there continental drift, resulting in the creation of mountain
ranges and earthquakes? Why is the earth's crust so restless, constantly
changing, sinking and rising, thereby causing vast changes in climate that are
most harmful to plants and animals?
Why did the Designer create species that literally war upon one another:
big fish eating little fish, little fish eating smaller plankton, microscopic
bacteria and viruses preying upon humans, and humans in turn fighting and
killing these germs?
Why is there such a redundancy of organs to accomplish the same function,
like two lungs, two kidneys and two sets of toes (or any toes at all)?
Why is nature so inefficient? Why, for instance, does the human male need
upwards of two-million sperm to impregnate just one female egg?
Why are parts of the human body inadequate for their functions, like
birth canals that are too small? Why can't our teeth be replaced like those of
Why are there parts of the human body that no longer have a function,
like the appendix, male breasts, pubic hair?
When constructing a human brain and its attached body, why is it
necessary for one cell to divide into a collection of cells that looks something
like an invertebrate called an ascidian (e.g., a sea squirt), then changes
course to head in the direction of a shark's elongated body form, then shifts
toward a proper fish's gills, then scraps the gills after a few weeks and
remakes the body into the image of a reptile, then into that of a primitive
mammal, then realigns things into the primate ape format, and finally, with some
fine tuning of the relative growth rates, grows into the big brain we humans
Why is the wiring of the brain so mixed up, where the nerves from the
right side of the body cross to the left side somewhere in the spinal cord or
brainstem, and go to the left cerebral cortex, making our right-hand movement
commands start from the left cortex and then cross over to the right side in the
brainstem, finally exiting to go to the muscles on the right side of the body?
Why does the Designer create misfits-midgets, hermaphrodites,
retardates, victims of genetic diseases, homosexuals and lesbians-ironically
the very people who do not want to perpetuate the species?
Why is the cloaca (klow AH kah)-the common opening for the intestine,
kidneys and reproductive organs-so primitive that they lead to many problems
for women (let alone greatly detracting from romance)?
Why are some species at an evolutionary dead end, like the sponges? Why
have echinoderms (ee KY no durms) sea lilies, sea stars, brittle stars, sea
urchins, sand dollars, sea cucumbers-regressed instead of evolving? (They
apparently once developed a longitudinal and bilateral body plan, and then
reverted back to the more primitive radial plan.)
If the Designer had done its work intelligently, why has man had to
improve upon the Designer's results through man's artificial selection of
flowers, crop plants, livestock and other animals of particular interest to
Why do animal populations outrun the vegetation needed for food? Why
didn't the Designer provide birth control methods that work better?
Why aren't human protected against the overloads of allergens?
Why didn't the Designer inform the majority of people that their
intuitions and personal belief systems about religion were mere fantasy, based
on animism; that they do not share a world with a population of extraordinary,
extra-corporeal, and invisible beings, ranging from souls and ghosts to saints
and fairies, angels and cherubim, demons, jinn, devils, gods and goddesses-that,
in fact, the Intelligent Designer never existed in the first place?
Published in the November/December issue of the
American Rationalist ©.
« Światopogląd (Publikacja: 26-10-2003 )
Wszelkie prawa zastrzeżone. Prawa autorskie tego tekstu należą do autora i/lub serwisu Racjonalista.pl.
Żadna część tego tekstu nie może być przedrukowywana, reprodukowana ani wykorzystywana w jakiejkolwiek formie,
bez zgody właściciela praw autorskich. Wszelkie naruszenia praw autorskich podlegają sankcjom przewidzianym w
kodeksie karnym i ustawie o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych.